Is It Worth it To Repair My Old Swim Spa Or Should I Buy a New One?

Disaster has struck and your swim spa is damaged. Whether it’s a crack in the structure or a mechanical failure, here’s what you want to know: Do you buy a new one or repair your existing one?

Of course, there are other scenarios, such as when you buy a new house and inherit a broken swim spa. Still, the question is the same. So, here’s what we’ll show you to answer it.

• Discover the real costs of repair vs. buying new
• Learn how to diagnose the problem for a good repair estimate
• See which problems are fatal and which should be repaired

Stay with us to find out what’s best for you and your swim spa. Dive in to make an informed decision today!

Is It Worth To Repair My Old Swim Spa Or Buy a New One? TL;DR

Repairing your old swim spa can be cost-effective if the issues are minor and your warranty is active. However, if repair costs are close to, or exceed the price of a new unit, or if you want modern features and better energy efficiency, investing in a new swim spa is worth it. Always compare costs and benefits to make the best decision.

What is the Problem? Learn How to Make a Diagnosis

Okay, the first step in the process is discovering the problem. You should start with the symptoms. These could include:

• Low or completely depleted water level indicates a leak somewhere. Finding the leak will be a challenge but is possible.
• Really bad water quality, algae, and mildew issues are either simple to fix with better water chemistry monitoring and fresh water or they could indicate a problem with the circulation and filtration.
• Low or no flow in the swim spa is going to be a problem with the machinery, such as the filtration and swim pumps.
• Cold water or water not staying at the correct temperature usually shows a problem with the heater element, but could also be a leak causing lots of new, colder water to circulate in the swim spa.

These are the most common things you’ll see in a swim spa. Even though there are simple solutions to them, the symptoms could be pointing at a much bigger problem.

For example, a leak in the swim spa could actually be caused by shifting foundations, which might require tearing out the whole thing to fix properly. This would be really expensive and hot tub owners and swim spa owners alike know this might be the time to buy a new units.

What you need is to dig into the problem a little and see where the real issues are so you can estimate how much the repairs will cost.

Let’s take a look at a few things that should influence your choice.

Several key factors should influence your decision

• Cost of Repairs: Calculate the total swim spa repair costs and compare them to the price of a new swim spa. Consider long-term maintenance expenses.
  
• Age of the Swim Spa: Older swim spas may have outdated technology, inefficiency, and may not adhere to current safety standards. For more info, read How Long Does a Swim Spa Last?
  
• Current Condition: Assess the condition of your swim spa. Look for signs of significant wear and tear, such as leaks, malfunctioning jets, or cracked shells.
  
• Warranty: Check if your swim spa is still under warranty. This can significantly reduce repair costs. New units often come with extended warranties.
  
• Energy Efficiency: New models are generally more energy-efficient, potentially offering significant savings on utility bills.
  
• Personal Use and Preferences: Consider how frequently you use the swim spa and your satisfaction with its current features. Newer models may offer improved functionality and comfort.
  

Evaluating these factors carefully will help you decide the best course of action that balances cost, efficiency, and satisfaction with your swim spa. Let’s take a look at each one in more detail.

Assessing the Condition of Your Current Swim Spa

One of life’s truisms is you get what you pay for. Quality brands and premium brands will almost certainly last longer than entry models. This makes evaluating the initial quality of your swim spa pretty important. If it’s a top model from one of the expensive brands, you might be justified in paying more for repairs.

Age and Wear

Now, consider the age of your swim spa. Swim spas over 10 years may face more frequent issues. Components like pumps, heaters, and jets degrade over time. Regular use can increase wear and tear, resulting in lower performance and efficiency. Check the condition of the shell, ensuring there are no significant cracks or leaks. Repairs on older models may be costlier due to outdated parts.

Common Issues and Repairs

Identify common issues with your current swim spa. Problems can include malfunctioning pumps, heater failures, and leaks. Pumps and motors often require professional repair for optimal operation. Heater failures may impact water temperature regulation. Leaks can stem from plumbing issues or shell damage. Assess these common issues:

• Pumps and Motors: Malfunctions or reduced efficiency.
  
• Heaters: Inconsistent water temperature.
  
• Leaks: Plumbing or structural shell issues.
  

Repairs might involve replacing faulty components or sealing leaks, impacting overall cost and feasibility. Of course, these could be offset by better swim spa maintenance.

Cost of Repairs

You can’t really make a solid choice about repair vs replacement without knowing the problem. But once you’ve diagnosed the problem, you can get an estimate for repairing it. There are really two things to think about here:

• Major repairs are almost certainly going to push you towards a similar cost for replacing the spa instead of repairing it.
• Pay attention to age and the kind of repair needed. If it’s a “wear and tear” repair, it may be likely to be the first of a few. This might make replacing the spa more cost-effective instead of paying for the first of four or five repairs.

Once you have an estimate, you can make a choice.

Benefits of Repairing Your Swim Spa

While replacing a swim spa keeps us in business, it’s not always the best choice. Here are a few reasons why repairs might be the best choice.

Cost-Effectiveness

Repairing your old swim spa often proves more cost-effective than purchasing a new one. Repairs can address most issues at a fraction of the cost of a new unit. Common repairs may include replacing pumps, fixing leaks, and updating outdated components. Investing in repairs instead of a complete replacement helps you save money while still enjoying all the benefits of your swim spa.

Sentimental Value

Your swim spa may hold significant sentimental value. It has likely been a place for relaxation, family gatherings, and exercise. Repairing your old swim spa allows you to maintain these cherished memories and experiences. Keeping a swim spa that is familiar and filled with positive associations can add to your overall satisfaction and well-being.

Environmental Considerations

Choosing to repair your swim spa instead of discarding it and buying a new one has positive environmental implications. The swim spa industry consumes resources and energy in manufacturing new units. By repairing your old swim spa, you contribute to reducing waste and conserving resources. This eco-friendly choice aligns with sustainable practices and helps you minimize your environmental footprint. For further insights and personal experiences on repairing swim spas, consider checking out this community discussion.

Downsides of Repairing Your Swim Spa

Of course, replacing a swim spa might also be a smarter choice. We think there are some reasons why repairing a spa could lead to other issues.

Recurring Maintenance Issues

When repairing your old swim spa, you may face ongoing maintenance problems. Aging parts tend to break down more frequently, leading to increased repair demands. Parts like pumps, heaters, and jets require constant attention. 

Potential for Hidden Costs

Repairing an old swim spa can involve hidden costs. Initial repairs might seem affordable, but unforeseen issues often arise. Problems such as leaks or electrical faults could remain undetected initially. These hidden problems can lead to sudden, costly repairs.

Lifespan Limitation

An older swim spa has a limited lifespan even after repairs. No matter the extent of your efforts, older components simply wear out faster. Eventually, the core structure and major hardware will fail. The cumulative cost of continuous repairs may end up being comparable to buying a new unit, without offering the same peace of mind.

Advantages of Buying a New Swim Spa

Beyond cost, there are some good reasons to get a new swim spa. Let’s take a look at each one of these.

Latest Technology and Features

New swim spas come equipped with the latest technology and features. Advanced filtration systems ensure cleaner water. Top-of-the-line models offer improved jet placement for optimal massage. Newer systems boast better digital controls for easier operation. Bluetooth connectivity and built-in speakers enhance your experience. New models offer customizable lighting options, providing greater ambiance.

Energy Efficiency

Modern swim spas are more energy-efficient. Enhanced insulation helps maintain water temperature. Energy-efficient pumps and heaters reduce operating costs. Smart technology features can optimize energy consumption. Some models come with energy-efficient LED lights. Look for swim spas with energy-efficient certifications. Buying one of the best swim spa covers will also make a huge difference.

Warranty and Support

Buying a new swim spa often includes extra warranty coverage. A manufacturer warranty can save you money on repairs. Manufacturers provide better support for newer models. Customer service is usually more accessible for recent purchases. Warranty coverage ensures peace of mind. Ultimately, investing in a new swim spa provides better features, lower operational costs, and dependable backing from manufacturers.

Challenges of Purchasing a New Swim Spa

Initial Cost

The initial new swim spa installation cost can be quite substantial. Swim spas generally range between $10,000 to $30,000 depending on the brand, features, and size. While financing options may be available, the upfront expenses are significant. Evaluating your budget and financial readiness is crucial before making the purchase.

Installation Requirements

Installing a new swim spa demands more than simply purchasing the unit. You need to account for site preparation, which may involve excavation, electrical work, and plumbing. Additional costs for labor and installation services can add up. Ensuring your property complies with local codes and regulations is also essential. Neglecting these aspects can result in unexpected delays and expenditures.

Learning Curve for New Features

New swim spas come with advanced features like improved water jets, digital controls, and energy efficiency settings. These enhancements require time to understand and use effectively. Familiarizing yourself with new functionalities might involve reading manuals or even hiring professionals for training. With a new swim spa, the initial learning curve can be steep, potentially impacting your enjoyment and ease of use until you are fully comfortable with the system. Swim Spa Owners Community

Making Your Decision

Comparing Total Costs

Begin by calculating the current value of your old swim spa. Factor in the cost of repairs, including parts and labor, compared to the cost of buying a new one. Technology in swim spas has evolved, offering energy-efficient models that may save you money on utilities. Obtain quotes for both repair and replacement and compare them closely.

Don’t forget additional expenses such as delivery, installation, and disposal of your old spa. Consider potential resale value if you decide to sell your old unit. It may influence your decision towards repairing or buying new.

Assessing Long-Term Needs

Analyze your long-term requirements. If your old swim spa meets your current and future needs, repair may be the right choice. However, if you foresee changes in usage patterns or if newer models offer features that better suit your needs, investing in a new swim spa might be beneficial.

Consider energy efficiency, advanced features, and warranty options available with new models. Newer swim spas typically come with longer warranties and better energy efficiency, which can lead to cost savings over time. Evaluate these factors against the age and condition of your current unit.

Getting Professional Advice

Consult with a professional technician to assess the condition of your old swim spa. A specialist can provide a detailed report on any necessary repairs and their associated costs, offering a clear picture of the investment required to restore your spa. They can also advise on the latest models and their benefits.

Review customer experiences and gather insights from online forums and reviews. For instance, browsing through discussions in communities like this Reddit thread can provide you with real-world feedback and help you make a more informed choice. Evaluating both professional opinions and user experiences ensures a well-rounded decision.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How much does it cost to repair an old swim spa?

Repair costs for an old swim spa can range from $200 for minor issues to over $2,000 for significant repairs. Factors include parts, labor, and the complexity of the problem.

What are signs that my swim spa needs a replacement?

Common signs include frequent repairs, significant wear and tear, outdated technology, or if the repair costs exceed half the price of buying a new one.

Are there benefits to repairing an old swim spa?

Repairing your swim spa can extend its life, save money in the short term, and maintain features you already love. It is also environmentally friendly compared to disposal.

What are the advantages of buying a new swim spa?

A new swim spa offers updated technology, energy efficiency, warranty, and improved features. It can also be more cost-effective in the long run if maintenance and repair costs are high for the old unit.

How do I evaluate if my old swim spa is worth repairing?

Consider the age of the spa, frequency of past repairs, current condition, cost of repairs versus the price of a new unit, and any sentimental value it holds.

Does warranty affect the decision to repair or replace?

If your swim spa is still under warranty, repairs may be covered, reducing out-of-pocket expenses. If it’s out of warranty, replacement might be more financially viable.

Conclusion

The best choice is not always clear. That’s why it makes sense to contact a good dealer. Our team here at Epic Hot Tubs can help you. We’ll recommend a good expert to assess your repairs and give you an estimate. We can also help you find and cost a replacement swim spa. If you want a no pressure chat to make a decision, we’re happy to help.

Interested in a swim spa in NC?

Your Name*

First Name Last Name

Email Address*

Phone Number

Message

By submitting this form, you are consenting to our privacy policy.

Email

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

About The Author:

Manny Brambila

Pool & Spa Expert

Manny has been in the Pool & Spa industry for over 15 years and is considered a pool, swim spa, & hot tub expert. He has been a Certified Pool & Spa Operator (CPO) since 2009 and worked 15 years in aquatic training and development for the largest pool chemical and customer care company. He also has been an outside consultant for the Pool and Spa industry in Chicago, New York and Los Angeles since 2018. In the past few years Manny has become Director of Operations for Epic Hot Tubs with a priority of providing customers with the most reliable information and best service possible.